Who Is Peter Sullivan?
Peter Sullivan is a man from the north-west of England who spent 38 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. He was convicted in 1987 of the sexual assault and killing of Diane Sindall in Bebington, near Liverpool, but his conviction was overturned by the Court of Appeal in May 2025 after new DNA evidence proved he could not have been the perpetrator.
Sullivan was 68 years old when he was finally freed. He wept in court as his conviction was quashed, and afterwards said that he was “not angry” despite losing nearly four decades of his life to a wrongful imprisonment. His case has since led to a major investigation by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) into how Merseyside Police handled the original inquiry.
What Was Peter Sullivan Accused Of?
Peter Sullivan was accused of the murder of Diane Sindall, a 21-year-old florist from Merseyside who was killed in August 1986. Diane was engaged to be married and had been working a part-time shift at a pub when her van ran out of fuel on her way home. She was last seen walking along the road after midnight.
Her body was discovered approximately 12 hours later in an alleyway in Bebington. She had been sexually assaulted and subjected to a severe beating. The case horrified the local community and police launched a major investigation to find her killer.
Peter Sullivan was arrested, charged, and convicted of the murder in 1987. He maintained his innocence throughout his entire time in prison but his appeals were repeatedly rejected. He became known in some circles as the “Wolfman” case, a reference to elements of the investigation at the time.
Why Was Peter Sullivan Wrongly Jailed?
Peter Sullivan was wrongly jailed primarily because the forensic science available at the time of his 1987 conviction was not sophisticated enough to properly analyse the biological evidence found at the scene. Sexual fluid recovered from Diane Sindall’s body could not be fully tested using the technology available in the 1980s.
Decades later, advances in DNA analysis made it possible to carry out a definitive test. In 2024, that test was finally conducted — and it revealed that the DNA did not belong to Peter Sullivan. This single piece of evidence was enough to demolish the case against him. The prosecution did not oppose the appeal, with barrister Duncan Atkinson stating that if DNA evidence of this kind had been available at the time of the original investigation, it was inconceivable that Sullivan would ever have been prosecuted.
When Was Peter Sullivan’s Conviction Overturned?
Peter Sullivan’s conviction was quashed on 13 May 2025 by the Court of Appeal. The judgment was handed down by Lord Justice Holroyde, Mr Justice Goss, and Mr Justice Bryan. Sullivan was present in court and broke down in tears as the verdict was read. He was immediately eligible for release following the ruling.
His case was referred to the Court of Appeal by the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), the body responsible for reviewing potential miscarriages of justice in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland. The CCRC welcomed the outcome and noted the significance of the new scientific evidence that had been developed years after Sullivan’s original trial.
What Has Happened Since His Release?
Following his release in May 2025, Peter Sullivan faced the challenge of rebuilding his life after nearly 40 years wrongful imprisonment. He may be entitled to significant compensation under the government’s scheme for those who have had convictions overturned, though the exact amount is subject to a formal application process.
The question of who actually killed Diane Sindall remains open. In January 2026, Merseyside Police offered a £20,000 reward for information leading to the conviction of her real killer. The IOPC is also conducting an independent investigation into Merseyside Police’s handling of the original inquiry and whether errors were made that contributed to the wrongful conviction of Sullivan.
What Are the Wider Implications of the Case?
The Peter Sullivan case has renewed debate about the reliability of pre-DNA era criminal convictions in the UK. Legal commentators have warned that his case should not be treated as an isolated incident, and that there may be other prisoners serving time for crimes they did not commit based on similarly outdated forensic evidence.
If you have a family member in prison and want to understand more about the UK prison and justice system, our guides on the Parole Board, booking a prison visit, and sending money to a prisoner may be helpful. For those affected by miscarriages of justice, the CCRC provides a formal route for having convictions reviewed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was Peter Sullivan wrongly jailed?
Peter Sullivan was wrongly jailed because the DNA technology needed to analyse biological evidence from the crime scene did not exist at the time of his 1987 conviction. When a DNA test was finally carried out in 2024, it proved the evidence did not match Sullivan, leading to his conviction being overturned in May 2025.
How long did Peter Sullivan spend in prison?
Peter Sullivan spent approximately 38 years in prison before his conviction was overturned by the Court of Appeal on 13 May 2025. He was 68 years old at the time of his release.
Who was Diane Sindall?
Diane Sindall was a 21-year-old florist from Merseyside who was sexually assaulted and murdered in Bebington in August 1986. She was engaged to be married and had been walking home after her van ran out of fuel. Her killer has still not been identified or convicted.
Has Peter Sullivan received compensation?
As of 2026, Peter Sullivan is likely to be eligible to apply for compensation under the government scheme for wrongful convictions. The exact amount would be determined through a formal process, but 38 years of wrongful imprisonment represents one of the longest miscarriages of justice in modern UK history.
Who is investigating the Peter Sullivan case?
The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) launched an investigation into Merseyside Police following Sullivan’s conviction being quashed. The IOPC is examining how the original investigation was conducted and whether police conduct contributed to the wrongful conviction.